‘28 4-star qb trey tagliaferri decommits
Notre Dame thought it had solved its quarterback puzzle for the 2028 class. Instead, the Irish are right back where they started — and the way it unraveled has raised real questions about how the staff handled the position this cycle.
A Commitment That Barely Lasted a Week
Trey Tagliaferri, a four-star quarterback out of Bergen Catholic in Oradell, New Jersey, visited South Bend on June 21 and silently committed to Notre Dame that weekend. He made it public on June 25, telling reporters the visit had sealed the deal. "Great people, a great place and a place that seems like really a family and all together," he said of the program at the time.
Six days later, on July 1, Tagliaferri reversed course and announced his decommitment. It's one of the shortest-lived pledges in recent Notre Dame recruiting history, and it left head coach Marcus Freeman, quarterbacks coach Gino Guidugli and the offensive staff needing to regroup at the sport's most important position.
Tagliaferri is no afterthought of a recruit. In 11 games during his first year as a starter, he completed 131 of 211 passes (62 percent) for 2,215 yards with 29 touchdowns against just three interceptions, adding a rushing score as well. He picked up All-State third-team and All-Bergen County first-team honors and enters his junior year rated anywhere from a three-star, No. 19 quarterback on 247Sports to a four-star, top-15 passer on the 247Sports Composite and Rivals industry rankings — a consensus top-20 quarterback nationally with 34 offers to his name.
The Oklahoma Connection
The most telling detail in this saga is who benefited from it. Almost immediately after Tagliaferri walked back his Notre Dame commitment, Rivals' prediction model shot to a 93.3 percent likelihood he ends up at Oklahoma, as Steve Wiltfong of On3/Rivals logged crystal ball picks sending him to Norman. Sooner Illustrated reported that Oklahoma "had quite a bit to do" with the flip, having pushed hard for Tagliaferri even while he was technically committed to the Irish.
That tracks with reporting on how this recruitment actually developed. Tagliaferri has been fond of Oklahoma for a long time, and the Sooners likely would have been the favorite from the jump had they pursued him earlier. Before Notre Dame entered the picture, there was real doubt about whether Oklahoma even viewed Tagliaferri as a lock at the position. Once he was off the board with the Irish, though, Oklahoma suddenly got serious — and once he was back on the market, the Sooners moved fast.
It's a pattern college football has seen before: a recruit uses a competing commitment to force a program's hand, then leverages that offer to get the outcome he wanted from his actual top choice all along. Whether or not that was the calculated intent here, the optics line up. Tagliaferri picked Notre Dame over Oklahoma and Penn State when he committed on Father's Day weekend — and then, less than a week later, all signs point to Oklahoma anyway.
Odd Timing From the Start
Beyond the flip itself, the timeline raises questions about Notre Dame's approach at quarterback this cycle. When Tagliaferri committed, the Irish still had active offers out to two other 2028 passers: Kingston Preyear, the No. 44 overall prospect and a top-five quarterback nationally who had visited South Bend and left with strong impressions of the program, and Lukas Prock, a Hun School (Princeton, N.J.) product with 39 offers who threw for over 4,300 yards as a sophomore.
The Irish staff reportedly made a deliberate call to lock in Tagliaferri rather than wait on Preyear, who had opted to keep his recruitment open a bit longer. Notre Dame has typically preferred to secure its quarterback target well ahead of schedule — the program has made a habit of getting its 2028-caliber signal-callers on board early, mirroring how it wrapped up commitments from Champ Monds and Teddy Jarrard in advance of their own cycles. Taking the more "available" quarterback in Tagliaferri, rather than continuing to build with a higher-ranked target like Preyear who still had Notre Dame near the top of his list, is now looking like a curious decision in hindsight — the staff prioritized getting a name in the class over letting a stronger recruitment play out.
It's also not the first time Notre Dame has been burned by uncertainty at the position. The program's experience with Deuce Knight in the 2025 cycle reportedly shaped this year's approach, pushing the staff toward wanting a "safer," lower-maintenance commitment. Instead, Tagliaferri turned into the exact kind of instability the staff was trying to avoid.
Where Does That Leave Notre Dame?
The Preyear outcome is a complicating factor for any plan to simply pivot back to him. Around the same time Tagliaferri was reversing course, Preyear announced he had trimmed his list to three finalists — Alabama, Florida and Vanderbilt — with a commitment date set for July 10. Notre Dame did not make the cut. Preyear had, in fact, been a silent Notre Dame commit earlier in the process, but his father reportedly encouraged him to slow down and gather more information before locking anything in, and that pause ultimately steered him toward an SEC-only finalist list. In other words, the quarterback many assumed would be Notre Dame's fallback option has already moved on, and it looks like a straight three-team race in his home region from here.
That leaves Prock as the more realistic in-house target still on the board, along with whatever new names the staff evaluates over the rest of the summer. Notre Dame does have other quarterbacks already ticketed for the program in future classes — Blake Hebert, Noah Grubbs, Teddy Jarrard and Champ Monds are all part of the pipeline — which takes some of the sting out of an empty spot in the 2028 class for now. But after landing and then immediately losing its presumptive 2028 quarterback, and watching its other top target trim Notre Dame off her list days later, the Irish staff is facing a real choice: continue chasing Prock and whichever late-emerging names surface, or take a step back entirely and re-evaluate the board at the position before committing to anyone else this cycle.
Given how quickly Tagliaferri's commitment came together and how quickly it fell apart, patience may be the more valuable asset than speed the next time around.
